The Cornerstone of Upper Body Strength: The Pullup
Options
Replies
-
Can you explain the difference between chin-ups and pull-ups?
Is it just what muscles you use? Don't they essentially look the same?
Chin-ups:
Main Muscle Worked: Biceps
Other Muscles Worked: Forearms, Lats
Equipment: BodyOnly
Mechanics Type: Compound
Pull-ups:
Main Muscle Worked: Lats
Other Muscles Worked: Biceps, Middle Back
Equipment: BodyOnly
Mechanics Type: Compound
If you've ever tried chin-ups for one month, and pull-ups in another month, you will know the difference. Chins hit the biceps harder and more directly as 50-70% of the movement utilizes the biceps, it isn't until the last 30% where you start contracting your lats which really makes it a back exercise.
Pull-ups on the other hand, almost instantly requires the lats to pull you up. After about 10% of the movement, your laterals become predominant.
Thanks! Is hip drive a safe technique for both of these or just the pullup?0 -
Can you explain the difference between chin-ups and pull-ups?
Is it just what muscles you use? Don't they essentially look the same?
Chin-ups:
Main Muscle Worked: Biceps
Other Muscles Worked: Forearms, Lats
Equipment: BodyOnly
Mechanics Type: Compound
Pull-ups:
Main Muscle Worked: Lats
Other Muscles Worked: Biceps, Middle Back
Equipment: BodyOnly
Mechanics Type: Compound
If you've ever tried chin-ups for one month, and pull-ups in another month, you will know the difference. Chins hit the biceps harder and more directly as 50-70% of the movement utilizes the biceps, it isn't until the last 30% where you start contracting your lats which really makes it a back exercise.
Pull-ups on the other hand, almost instantly requires the lats to pull you up. After about 10% of the movement, your laterals become predominant.
Thanks! Is hip drive a safe technique for both of these or just the pullup?
Mmm...I don't know if I would do hip drive on a chinup because of the direct bicep involvement.0 -
Thanks Joe! I'm tired of falling off those monkey bars in my mud runs! I NEED to conquer them!0
-
I mean......................Opinions can vary on this. Chinups and Pullups are a mans exercise no doubt.
But for me to call it the best its hard to overlook things such as bench, squats, deads. Chinups/Pullups are right there though.
The information and quality of the post is there and many will learn from it so thats a gret job by you
But in the scenario below I will take the dealifter
And I will use PHRAK the guy who posted above
Phrak. Who can deadlift 800 lbs but onlyp ullup his wiehgt 4 times
vs
SUPER HUMAN 10000 PULLUP GUY
PHRAK=WINNER
FACT
Chinups/Pullups don't involve your legs. The biggest muscle on the human body
Squats/Deads/Bench do.0 -
This is awesome info! I used to NEVER be able to do a pullup. Now I can do 2 in a row! I can do 4 with palms facing me It just takes a lot of practice and time. Now I can't wait til I can do more!!0
-
Pullups are awesome!
As a female, there is nothing more satisfying when finishing a workout to be able to bang out 10 chinups and 6 pullups!
It took me 2 months and I could barely do one of each.
Pullups are def more challenging but I can do the chinups from deadweight start and spot on form.
Love em!0 -
This DEFINITELY needs to be stickied, this is so helpful!
Stickying this to my profile page. Thanx Joe!0 -
bump0
-
Thanks! Bump!0
-
Something to work towards, thanks for the info, Joe.0
-
Great info. Thanks!0
-
Great info! Thanks!
Pull ups are way harder, but working on them!0 -
Good post, but I have to disagree on the difference b/w pull-ups and chin-ups.
Pull-ups don't have anymore back involvement than chin-ups. Just think about where the muscles attach. They dont' attach to your forearm! The reason chin-ups are easier is b/c you have more biceps activation. So you're just using more muscles, which is why the chin-up is the real king of upper body exercises and has been proven to activate more upper-body muscles to exercise levels than any other upper body exercise.
You couldn't be more wrong.
The difference b/w them has been beaten to death pretty much everywhere. Bottom line is that they aren't much different, except that the chin-up includes more biceps activation which is why they're "easier" and probably more bang for your buck. Yes there are other slight nuances such as forearms likely being worked more with pull-ups. But if you want the details:A study about the differences between pull-ups and chin-ups, using EMG analysis, was published in the December 2010 issue of the Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research. The researchers found that both variations of the exercise were initiated by the lower trapezius and pectoralis major, and then completed by the biceps brachii and latissimus. The major differences are that chin-ups more strongly activated the pectoralis major and biceps brachii than the pull-up, whereas the pull-up more strongly activated the lower trapezius than the chin-up. To this I would add that pull-ups work the forearm muscles more and tend to put less stress on the wrists and elbows.
Further, the study found that both variations were initiated by the lower trapezius and pectoralis major, and then completed by the biceps brachii and latissimus. However, consider that because the lats are internal rotators of the shoulders, chin-ups are not a good exercise to reverse round shoulders.
Link to the study:
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/206643640 -
Good post, but I have to disagree on the difference b/w pull-ups and chin-ups.
Pull-ups don't have anymore back involvement than chin-ups. Just think about where the muscles attach. They dont' attach to your forearm! The reason chin-ups are easier is b/c you have more biceps activation. So you're just using more muscles, which is why the chin-up is the real king of upper body exercises and has been proven to activate more upper-body muscles to exercise levels than any other upper body exercise.
You couldn't be more wrong.
The difference b/w them has been beaten to death pretty much everywhere. Bottom line is that they aren't much different, except that the chin-up includes more biceps activation which is why they're "easier" and probably more bang for your buck. Yes there are other slight nuances such as forearms likely being worked more with pull-ups. But if you want the details:A study about the differences between pull-ups and chin-ups, using EMG analysis, was published in the December 2010 issue of the Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research. The researchers found that both variations of the exercise were initiated by the lower trapezius and pectoralis major, and then completed by the biceps brachii and latissimus. The major differences are that chin-ups more strongly activated the pectoralis major and biceps brachii than the pull-up, whereas the pull-up more strongly activated the lower trapezius than the chin-up. To this I would add that pull-ups work the forearm muscles more and tend to put less stress on the wrists and elbows.
Further, the study found that both variations were initiated by the lower trapezius and pectoralis major, and then completed by the biceps brachii and latissimus. However, consider that because the lats are internal rotators of the shoulders, chin-ups are not a good exercise to reverse round shoulders.
Link to the study:
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20664364
Vanilla and Chocolate. Mix it up and you will be alright.
It is a great post0 -
Bump0
-
great info!0
-
If my surviving a zombie apocalypse is dependent on me being able to do pull ups, I'm so dead.0
-
Thanks for posting Joe!0
-
Thanks Joe!! We actually just got a pull up bar thinnger last night!! The Boy will be happy to have this info too!!0
-
Excellent read Joe. I am using the assisted machine so I guess from your post I should NOT be. ;o) I will search out the appropriate machine at the gym and get on this.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 391.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.5K Getting Started
- 259.7K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.6K Food and Nutrition
- 47.3K Recipes
- 232.3K Fitness and Exercise
- 393 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.4K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 152.7K Motivation and Support
- 7.8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.3K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 939 Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.3K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions