Welcome to Debate Club! Please be aware that this is a space for respectful debate, and that your ideas will be challenged here. Please remember to critique the argument, not the author.
The most polarizing food: where do you stand?
Replies
-
pancakerunner wrote: »Safari_Gal_ wrote: »just_Tomek wrote: »Absolute fav. soup. Beef Tripe.
From this....:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/tripe-56a8a78d3df78cf7729f6efd.jpg)
To this....
@just_Tomek
I’ve eaten some pretty funky things my liver loving friend! - but tripe is the one thing on my list that I can’t do!
I tried it in a restaurant in downtown NYC and I spit it out on my plate. My husband still says it was prepared incorrectly because it tasted like 🤮
I dunno. Maybe if it’s hidden in chocolate fondue and chased by some tequila. Maybe.
Ps- I still love haggis. 😬
Curious: does tripe have the same texture as morel mushrooms??? What does it taste like?
@pancakerunner /—- well it depends on how it’s prepared...I didn’t like it when i tried it. I don’t think it’s comparable to morels. To me it had a squishy texture that tasted like stomach acid. It probably wasn’t cleaned or prepared right ...next time I’m going to Canada to try @just_Tomek ‘s 😉
I say try it and report back! 😬0 -
1 -
pancakerunner wrote: »
Oh, God! It's like they took the world's most disgusting food and combined it with the world's SECOND-most disgusting food.6 -
Fois gras. I'm a hard no.0
-
Crafty_camper123 wrote: »Just got caught up on the whole food vs "non food" food thing. Which brings me to one polarizing question of which we should probably be debating about by now.
Cake or Death?
Apologies in advance, I know this specific comment was posted months ago, but I'm only reading the thread now: I
Eddie! 
Regarding the OP, I have no opinion on those cookies because I never had them, but I'd be willing to try them at least once.
As far as "polarizing foods" go, my take has always been "like it or leave it". We don't all have to like the same things, and it all comes down to personal preferences. 1 -
GummiMundi wrote: »Crafty_camper123 wrote: »Just got caught up on the whole food vs "non food" food thing. Which brings me to one polarizing question of which we should probably be debating about by now.
Cake or Death?
Apologies in advance, I know this specific comment was posted months ago, but I'm only reading the thread now: I Eddie!
Regarding the OP, I have no opinion on those cookies because I never had them, but I'd be willing to try them at least once.
As far as "polarizing foods" go, my take has always been "like it or leave it". We don't all have to like the same things, and it all comes down to personal preferences.
If you have Death by Chocolate, you can have your cake and eat it too. 1 -
just_Tomek wrote: »chelleedub wrote: »Fois gras. I'm a hard no.
Why?
I can't answer for the poster, but some people find the process of producing the fois gras to be particularly inhumane. Even a lot of people who normally eat animal products find this a bit too far on the cruelty side.3 -
SuzySunshine99 wrote: »just_Tomek wrote: »chelleedub wrote: »Fois gras. I'm a hard no.
Why?
I can't answer for the poster, but some people find the process of producing the fois gras to be particularly inhumane. Even a lot of people who normally eat animal products find this a bit too far on the cruelty side.
That's pretty much my reason for avoiding fois gras.0 -
SuzySunshine99 wrote: »just_Tomek wrote: »chelleedub wrote: »Fois gras. I'm a hard no.
Why?
I can't answer for the poster, but some people find the process of producing the fois gras to be particularly inhumane. Even a lot of people who normally eat animal products find this a bit too far on the cruelty side.
I may be wrong, but I was under the impression from another post that the poster's a vegetarian. That tends to make fois gras kind of a hard no, no matter what other sensitivities may enter into it.
0 -
it is banned in several countries because of the cruelty involved in force feeding.
I dont eat liver anyway so already a No from me - but would be a double no on account of that.0 -
just_Tomek wrote: »SuzySunshine99 wrote: »just_Tomek wrote: »chelleedub wrote: »Fois gras. I'm a hard no.
Why?
I can't answer for the poster, but some people find the process of producing the fois gras to be particularly inhumane. Even a lot of people who normally eat animal products find this a bit too far on the cruelty side.
But eggs from caged hens are ok? Ditto broiler chickens? Same thing. Bred and fed for one purpose only.
I myself dont like it, but thats for the taste and texture. Ditto bone marrow.
At least with some animal products you have choices you can make...you can buy cage-free eggs or free-range chickens. Sure, they are still eventually slaughtered, but at least you could reasonably think (or convince yourself) that they were not tortured and were killed quickly. You don't know, but can at least tell yourself that.
With fois gras, it is absolutely certain that the bird was tortured for weeks to achieve the desired product, and that can be a bit hard to justify.0 -
just_Tomek wrote: »SuzySunshine99 wrote: »just_Tomek wrote: »SuzySunshine99 wrote: »just_Tomek wrote: »chelleedub wrote: »Fois gras. I'm a hard no.
Why?
I can't answer for the poster, but some people find the process of producing the fois gras to be particularly inhumane. Even a lot of people who normally eat animal products find this a bit too far on the cruelty side.
But eggs from caged hens are ok? Ditto broiler chickens? Same thing. Bred and fed for one purpose only.
I myself dont like it, but thats for the taste and texture. Ditto bone marrow.
At least with some animal products you have choices you can make...you can buy cage-free eggs or free-range chickens. Sure, they are still eventually slaughtered, but at least you could reasonably think (or convince yourself) that they were not tortured and were killed quickly. You don't know, but can at least tell yourself that.
With fois gras, it is absolutely certain that the bird was tortured for weeks to achieve the desired product, and that can be a bit hard to justify.
That means nothing, you know that right? Also, even if the broilers could walk to the yard, they are still made to serve one purpose, grow large white meat that everyone wants now. And how do you know the bird is suffering? Just because the practice looks damaging or simply "not right"? Every seen a baby mammal being force fed via a tube to keep it alive? How is that different?
But thats a different topic.
I think I made it clear that I know that.
It’s about the perception, whether reality or not. Everyone decides for themselves where they want to draw their moral line, and my point was that for many people, this practice crosses that line for them. I’m not going to argue about what constitutes suffering and what doesn’t. I was just answering your question as to why someone would choose not to eat that particular food.2 -
pancakerunner wrote: »
Mouthwatering. I WISH I didn't have a sweet tooth and that I wasn't so delighted by these things (but I am... and YES, they're worth the calories for me). My challenge is to responsibly limit my consumption... I'm not going to give them up entirely.4 -
I'd rather have a homemade sugar cookie. Honestly, I rarely keep any type of cookie in the house because I've learned through the years that cookies are not a friend to my healthy weight maintenance. When I make them, I need to get the leftovers in the freezer ASAP0
-
I'd rather have a homemade sugar cookie. Honestly, I rarely keep any type of cookie in the house because I've learned through the years that cookies are not a friend to my healthy weight maintenance. When I make them, I need to get the leftovers in the freezer ASAP
Leftovers?just_Tomek wrote: »Here is one for you..... Salceson
Gross! I wouldn’t even let that in my kitchen!
0 -
Do I want to know what Salceson is made of?0
-
LOFTHOUSE COOKIES ARE THE DEVIL. They look so good, but they are so not good!
Polarizing foods.. I'm sure in 36 pages, sardines have been covered? I love sardines with crackers.0 -
My local grocery store had absolutely no bread, cheese, milk, or beans, and almost zero soup or frozen vegetables on Monday evening. You know what they had plenty of right at the front? Lofthouse "cookies".5
-
I always acknowledge that they are bad “cookies,” yet I still love them. I think it’s the texture. I can eat a whole box no problem, so I refuse to buy them for my own sake 😂1
-
Really polarizing foods are things like: 1) brain sandwiches, 2) barbecued pig snouts or 3) haggis, just sayin'.
I rather like haggis but only eat it on the occasional Burns night. Haven't tried snouts.
Don't like brain because I find it way too rich.
I had an Italian girlfriend whom I once told that I'm nog crazy about most organ meats. Chicken gizzards and livers and riz de veaux are the exceptions. Next time I came for dinner she served kidney, liver and brain because she was convinced I didn't like them because I hadn't had them cooked the Italian way. The kidney tasted of piss, the liver had the texture of sand and pan fried brain tasted like deep fried butter.2 -
just_Tomek wrote: »I will play........ Natto.
(snip image for reply length)
Good play !
I finally tried some recently, at a restaurant, after being curious about it for years (just not quite curious enough to search for it outside my usual shopping places). The waitress tried to talk me out of ordering it!
Maybe scary looking, but tastes good IMO.
When I tried to order this in a Japanese restaurant the waitress tried to talk me out of it too.0 -
The night before our wedding we took out our witnesses out to a fancy french restaurant. In the Netherlands the groom has two best men, and the bride has two maids of honor who all sign the marriage certificate.
One of the best men, when he saw calves testicles on the menu exclaimed to my hubby, "You need to order these on your wedding night, as an aphrodisiac!" My husband who does eat meat, but is squeamish about any meat that obviously looks like an animal (such as lobster or oysters) refused. So I agreed to order the starter of pan fried calves testicles.
Won't be doing that again. In the same way that lambs kidneys smell of piss, calves testicles taste of semen.2 -
Since moving from the Netherlands I really miss fillet americain. That's a sandwich spread made of finely ground raw beef sold in supermarkets.
https://www.tasteatlas.com/filet-americain
I have no idea how it got it's name, as it is a food that is as un-American as it gets.0 -
Since moving from the Netherlands I really miss fillet americain. That's a sandwich spread made of finely ground raw beef sold in supermarkets.
https://www.tasteatlas.com/filet-americain
I have no idea how it got it's name, as it is a food that is as un-American as it gets.
I love raw beef, but this looks unusual. Is anything added to it?0 -
pancakerunner wrote: »Since moving from the Netherlands I really miss fillet americain. That's a sandwich spread made of finely ground raw beef sold in supermarkets.
https://www.tasteatlas.com/filet-americain
I have no idea how it got it's name, as it is a food that is as un-American as it gets.
I love raw beef, but this looks unusual. Is anything added to it?
Here's a recipe. It is a low brow version of steak tartare. Sold in supermarkets in NL as a sandwich spread. I love raw beef and raw tuna too.
https://www.thedutchtable.com/2011/04/filet-americain.html0 -
how does this make you feel?1 -
actually, that makes me feel kind of queazy. That icing looks gritty up that close and just what are those discs supposed to be? I'll take the lofthouse cookies and you can keep the cupcake
3 -
pancakerunner wrote: »
how does this make you feel?
My tongue is practically licking that frosting up.
(I should really clean this tablet.)0 -
pancakerunner wrote: »
how does this make you feel?
Eh, not worth the calories, it doesn't look very good and I always love the sweets you post! I'd probably eat the icing and that's it.0 -
In South Carolina, I got into eating "slaw dogs." That's a hot dog on a bun with chili, onions and creamy coleslaw on top, ketchup and mustard optional. I liked mine with pimento cheese instead of chile and yes, please, to the ketchup and mustard. A hamburger done up in a similar fashion is termed "all the way."3
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions