How many times have you seen this? Some people don't get it!
Replies
-
Any ideas on what to eat after a workout so I don't turn in to an arrogant douche?
Anyone?
The chic next door?0 -
How many times have you seen people go to the gym and work their *kitten* off... only to stop at Wendy's or Mcdonald's after their workouts. Come on people, your body wants clean food! Or how many times have you heard "I'm not seeing any results" I ask what they had to eat for lunch and they say "I had to run to Arbys because I didn't bring my lunch."
You are what you eat! Sorry just venting a little lol.
Here's my reply, but I'll be the first to admit that I haven't read all 18 pages so perhaps some of this bears repeating.
Before I get into this, this is nothing personal towards the OP and I'm going on a tangent here:
If you're saying that people who casually exercise and use that as an excuse to go overeat a bunch of nutrient sparse foods thinking that their sub-par exercise justifies having a sub-par diet, then I would absolutely agree with your premise.
If you're saying that the individual food sources that you choose significantly matter towards your physique once macronutrient and micronutrient sufficiency are met (<-- key statement), then I would absolutely disagree with you and suggest that your results weren't due to the supposed cleanliness of your food, they were due to your training and your total nutrient intake.
Total nutrient intake is obviously composed of your individual food choices but as long as you are able to sufficiently nourish yourself, and as long as you're able to meet macronutrient demands for your body composition/training goals, then you've got an awful lot of leeway in selecting food items and "cleanliness" is certainly not a factor in the least.
http://www.bodyrecomposition.com/research-review/hormonal-responses-to-a-fast-food-meal-compared-with-nutritionally-comparable-meals-of-different-composition-research-review.html
http://www.wannabebig.com/diet-and-nutrition/the-dirt-on-clean-eating/
As an aside: Regarding the whole physique=knowledge thing, and we see it especially in juiced individuals (not saying this about the OP specifically). You get someone who is obviously jacked and lean, and they think they know what they're talking because:
I'm big and lean ---> I eat these foods ----> Therefore my results are due to these foods. (And you can replace food with just about anything else that gets discussed).
This is just crap logic.
I'm going to make a bold statement. You know who knows more than anyone on this site?
This guy:
Guess what? I'm going to wager that I'm more muscular and leaner than he is. I am going to wager that he knows WAAAAAAAAAAAY more than I do about fitness/nutrition. He's one of the best in the field.
So you can't necessarily equate physique to knowledge. That's a mistake and it's certainly not a justification for what sometimes can be crappy broscience.0 -
I don't think it's my business what other people eat. I have a hard enough time keeping up with what I'm eating!
Exactly! What and how another person meets or sets their requirements is based soley on their very own long term resutls. After a rigorous workout, the last thing that I am thinking about is eating McDs, but to each is own. I am working to improve me. :happy:0 -
Any ideas on what to eat after a workout so I don't turn in to an arrogant douche?
Anyone?
Snicker0 -
I feel like I've sinned or done something horribly wrong if I workout and then go to fast food.
Agreed. I don't do fast "food" Lol0 -
I don't make a habit of following random people home from the gym, so I have no idea what they eat.
I agree LOL0 -
What I see more often than that, is people who judge others for doing things they "feel' they are better than.
I can understand if someone wants to work their butt off so they can enjoy McD's or BK.
Running for 40 miunutes then gettting a BigMac is much better than just getting a BigMac.
I'm glad you shared your high horse though, I bet it made a bunch of people feel better about themselves.0 -
I'm getting the last word in!
Tacos.0 -
wasn't serious! I love me some beef..0
-
Thanks for your vent.How many times have you seen people go to the gym and work their *kitten* off... only to stop at Wendy's or Mcdonald's after their workouts. Come on people, your body wants clean food! Or how many times have you heard "I'm not seeing any results" I ask what they had to eat for lunch and they say "I had to run to Arbys because I didn't bring my lunch."
You are what you eat! Sorry just venting a little lol.
Luckily your opinion is just that, an opinion.
If someone works their *kitten* off and wants to treat themselves to a junk food meal for the day, LET THEM. I mean dont get me wrong if they are doing this every day then complaining then i guess that is a problem. however on occasion I see nothing wrong with this and my body proves that. We dont have to be perfect. We just need to be healthy.0 -
I'm getting the last word in!
Tacos.
My place or yours
0 -
For me, I have greater success when I work "non-clean" food into my diet.
WHAT??? Seriously????0 -
I'm getting the last word in!
Tacos.
My place or yours
When the question is "tacos" the answer is always yours.0 -
I'm getting the last word in!
Tacos.
My place or yours
When the question is "tacos" the answer is always yours.
:flowerforyou: :blushing: :blushing: :flowerforyou:0 -
I see this all the time.
It's not something I allow to bother me too much, especially since IT'S ME DOING IT :laugh:
Seriously, my results have been stellar, and I eat clean 70% of the time.
Nutrition can indeed wreck progress, but let's not get Nazi about it.0 -
My interpretation of the original post is that it is a judgement. I am not an expert on nutrition, fitness or psychology, in fact, I'm not really an expert on anything except me and even then I'm not so sure - but I'm good at googling.
"We may not consciously be aware that tearing down others can inflate ourselves. Yet the underlying message is something like, I wouldn’t think of doing such a thing, or I could never do that or I am shocked and aghast at such behavior. We are usually noting how utterly different we are from these people or how we would simply never sink to their level. Criticizing others is not just an offensive move against them; it is also a defensive move to protect our own “purity".When we are judgmental, therefore, we need other people’s faults in order to dodge our own. Stated simply, judgmental thinking is addicted to other people’s faults or destructive behavior. Judgmentalism finds its identity in what it is not".
- Terry Cooper 'Making Judgments without Being Judgmental: Nurturing a Clear Mind and a Generous Heart".
I'm not entirely comfortable with the source of this extract, and not knowing the author nor having read the book I don't know the true context of what he's saying, but I find interesting and I think it applies here. And I'm certainly not saying I'm not judgemental - I think we all are.0 -
I'm getting the last word in!
Tacos.
Oh, that would have rocked if the thread had ended right there.
Poop.0 -
How many times have you seen people go to the gym and work their *kitten* off... only to stop at Wendy's or Mcdonald's after their workouts. Come on people, your body wants clean food! Or how many times have you heard "I'm not seeing any results" I ask what they had to eat for lunch and they say "I had to run to Arbys because I didn't bring my lunch."
You are what you eat! Sorry just venting a little lol.
Here's my reply, but I'll be the first to admit that I haven't read all 18 pages so perhaps some of this bears repeating.
Before I get into this, this is nothing personal towards the OP and I'm going on a tangent here:
If you're saying that people who casually exercise and use that as an excuse to go overeat a bunch of nutrient sparse foods thinking that their sub-par exercise justifies having a sub-par diet, then I would absolutely agree with your premise.
If you're saying that the individual food sources that you choose significantly matter towards your physique once macronutrient and micronutrient sufficiency are met (<-- key statement), then I would absolutely disagree with you and suggest that your results weren't due to the supposed cleanliness of your food, they were due to your training and your total nutrient intake.
Total nutrient intake is obviously composed of your individual food choices but as long as you are able to sufficiently nourish yourself, and as long as you're able to meet macronutrient demands for your body composition/training goals, then you've got an awful lot of leeway in selecting food items and "cleanliness" is certainly not a factor in the least.
http://www.bodyrecomposition.com/research-review/hormonal-responses-to-a-fast-food-meal-compared-with-nutritionally-comparable-meals-of-different-composition-research-review.html
http://www.wannabebig.com/diet-and-nutrition/the-dirt-on-clean-eating/
As an aside: Regarding the whole physique=knowledge thing, and we see it especially in juiced individuals (not saying this about the OP specifically). You get someone who is obviously jacked and lean, and they think they know what they're talking because:
I'm big and lean ---> I eat these foods ----> Therefore my results are due to these foods. (And you can replace food with just about anything else that gets discussed).
This is just crap logic.
I'm going to make a bold statement. You know who knows more than anyone on this site?
This guy:
Guess what? I'm going to wager that I'm more muscular and leaner than he is. I am going to wager that he knows WAAAAAAAAAAAY more than I do about fitness/nutrition. He's one of the best in the field.
So you can't necessarily equate physique to knowledge. That's a mistake and it's certainly not a justification for what sometimes can be crappy broscience.
I am quoting this so this is hopefully the last thing on this thread as it is important for people to understand.
ETA: pants!...I rolled the bloody thing!0 -
AAAHHHH We started it all over again!! We have no one to blame but ourselves!!!0
-
At least Sara's quote of SideSteel's post is the first thing here.0
-
YAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAY!0
-
^True story.At least Sara's quote of SideSteel's post is the first thing here.0 -
*obligatory fat person who eats fast food* - god, I should be ashamed of myself.0
-
^True story.At least Sara's quote of SideSteel's post is the first thing here.
Obviously. I said it. It must inherently be true.0 -
Just seeing if we can get this one over 20 pages before (you know who) figures it out.0
-
I had a friend that would work out then eat McNuggets after to get his protein. Weird to me..
Oh, he was also a certified trainer.0 -
My food is always dirty. That's why I have to give it a good tongue lashing.
Wait. This might be the wrong thread. *wanders off, muttering something about Master Baiting*0 -
*obligatory fat person who eats fast food* - god, I should be ashamed of myself.
*hangs head* me too *sniff*0 -
How many times have you seen people go to the gym and work their *kitten* off... only to stop at Wendy's or Mcdonald's after their workouts. Come on people, your body wants clean food! Or how many times have you heard "I'm not seeing any results" I ask what they had to eat for lunch and they say "I had to run to Arbys because I didn't bring my lunch."
You are what you eat! Sorry just venting a little lol.
Here's my reply, but I'll be the first to admit that I haven't read all 18 pages so perhaps some of this bears repeating.
Before I get into this, this is nothing personal towards the OP and I'm going on a tangent here:
If you're saying that people who casually exercise and use that as an excuse to go overeat a bunch of nutrient sparse foods thinking that their sub-par exercise justifies having a sub-par diet, then I would absolutely agree with your premise.
If you're saying that the individual food sources that you choose significantly matter towards your physique once macronutrient and micronutrient sufficiency are met (<-- key statement), then I would absolutely disagree with you and suggest that your results weren't due to the supposed cleanliness of your food, they were due to your training and your total nutrient intake.
Total nutrient intake is obviously composed of your individual food choices but as long as you are able to sufficiently nourish yourself, and as long as you're able to meet macronutrient demands for your body composition/training goals, then you've got an awful lot of leeway in selecting food items and "cleanliness" is certainly not a factor in the least.
http://www.bodyrecomposition.com/research-review/hormonal-responses-to-a-fast-food-meal-compared-with-nutritionally-comparable-meals-of-different-composition-research-review.html
http://www.wannabebig.com/diet-and-nutrition/the-dirt-on-clean-eating/
As an aside: Regarding the whole physique=knowledge thing, and we see it especially in juiced individuals (not saying this about the OP specifically). You get someone who is obviously jacked and lean, and they think they know what they're talking because:
I'm big and lean ---> I eat these foods ----> Therefore my results are due to these foods. (And you can replace food with just about anything else that gets discussed).
This is just crap logic.
I'm going to make a bold statement. You know who knows more than anyone on this site?
This guy:
Guess what? I'm going to wager that I'm more muscular and leaner than he is. I am going to wager that he knows WAAAAAAAAAAAY more than I do about fitness/nutrition. He's one of the best in the field.
So you can't necessarily equate physique to knowledge. That's a mistake and it's certainly not a justification for what sometimes can be crappy broscience.
I am quoting this so this is hopefully the last thing on this thread as it is important for people to understand.
ETA: pants!...I rolled the bloody thing!
So... um...
Who is that guy?0 -
So... um...
Who is that guy?
Lyle McDonald.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions