Can husband motivate wife to lose lbs w/o being a jerk?

Options
1568101114

Replies

  • loves03
    loves03 Posts: 73 Member
    Options
    If your husband could have written this (and trust me, he didn't), then let me speak for your husband and say that 99.9% of the time he isn't at all worried or concerned about your imperfections, but instead appreciates all of the wonderful things that make the two of you happy together. He is busy appreciating everything that you do for him - the way you make him laugh, the many things you do to make his life more enjoyable, the great sex, the ways you make him want to be a better person, the moments you get to spend alone, and all of the other ways that you enrich his life. When he see's you in the nude, his eyes are instantly drawn to the parts of you that he loves best and his mind very quickly goes to the fun you two could have together (even if the kids are in the next room). When he does notice a small flaw here and there (and I'm not saying he does), he immediately feels bad for even noticing and reminds himself that he is lucky to be with you. If he notices that another woman is a bit fitter than you are, he instinctively reminds himself of everything in your life that makes it difficult for you to stay in perfect shape and assumes that the other woman doesn't have to worry about the same challenges. What I'm saying is that, just because men may sometimes notice imperfections in their wives and even if they are occasionally neanderthal enough to actually mention such imperfections to their wives (or start a cowardly internet thread discussing the issue in abstract), that doesn't mean that these men are constantly critiquing their wives or girlfriends or that they are unhappy in any way. I clicked "reply" without looking closely at your profile picture or other photos (so I can't say from personal observation), but you should trust that your husband finds you beautiful and sexy and know that you are much more aware of and obsessed with your imperfections that he is. Mostly, he's just happy you're there.

    You sound very nice. I can tell you really love your wife :) And I agree with most of the others....don't say anything that will be hurtful.
  • chubbygirl253
    chubbygirl253 Posts: 1,309 Member
    Options
    Suggest you guys get in shape together. Maybe you don't need to lose weight but you could use some toning up. Talk about what you would like to achieve for yourself. Leave her body and her goals out of it. Suggest starting slow like taking a yoga clas TOGETHER. Or suggest an activity that you know might help her areas that needed targeted the most. Like cycling to tone butt and legs.

    You can be very supportive by doing it with her. And as she feels empowered by her success she will probably find other ways to reach the next level, like diet. My fiance is so wonderful and supportive. When I told him I was starting this diet, he started one too. He congratulates me on every pound lost or milestone. He supports me through all my challenges and struggles. He is my biggest cheerleader. He never once said I need to lose weight but he's with me every step of the way. I know he loves me for who I am, whether I lose another pound or not. Just be generous with the affection and praise and you should be fine.
  • Robinvan38
    Robinvan38 Posts: 17 Member
    Options
    If you think she doesn't know, take a photo, but never say a word about her being overweight. Secondly, be aware that decreasing hormones play a big role on how the calories are metabolized. It may not be her her fault and there may not be anything she can do short of starvation. I could not loose weight until I read the book "Why we get fat and what to do about it" by Gary Taubes. After reading it, I immediately dropped 10 pounds without trying (and quit exercising so hard). Maybe pick up the book for you to read (and if you're lucky she will want to read it too). You also should know that there will ALWAYS be woman out there that are younger or have a more perfect shape. Be careful not to compare. And one more thing, I like your picture-I would be afraid to show my face too-lol.
  • polishmehappy
    polishmehappy Posts: 92 Member
    Options
    To the original poster:

    You sound like a kind husband and you really don't want to hurt your wife. Hats off to you!

    No matter how kind you are or how good your intentions may be, the probability that she will be hurt if you bring up the issue is very likely to happen. We women are that way :)

    But...you can adress the issue in a roundabout way. Be clever! Take care of yourself, your own body, your nutrition, your heart health, by eating right and staying active. Before you know it your spouse will join you:)

    And then when she does, don't say "I'm so glad you joined me in this..." No. Take her to a department store to shop for clothes (and shoes if possible). Make her feel sexy, beautiful, wanted. Make love to her until your joints hurt and sweat covers your sheets. Love her more each day, reward her for what she is doing for herself and for you:)

    It might all be really a lot easier than you think :) Good luck!
  • JenniBaby85
    JenniBaby85 Posts: 855 Member
    Options
    Thanks everyone. I appreciate that some of you were able to see that I do, in fact, love my wife very much and appreciate all of the many wonderful things about her. I was asking about a very small detail in our life together, kind of like someone noticing a leaf blower in the distance on a beautiful, peaceful, quiet summer day. It doesn't mean they aren't having the time of their life. I chose this forum of discussion because I felt it would be a way to get some meaningful, anonymous feedback with zero chance of hurting my wife's feelings. Don't forget, none of you know the first thing about either one of us other than the abstracted details that I shared. At the same time, I take no offense at those of you who assumed I was just another pig. It's natural, especially in this setting, and I intentionally hid all personal details that might have cast me in a more complimentary light.

    Really? Because I don't like hating people, so maybe you should put yourself in a more complementary light....
  • ajamesquinn
    Options
    Been there, tried that and the answer is a big NO.
  • dbanks80
    dbanks80 Posts: 3,685 Member
    Options
    For you women who might be interested in motivating your man to get into better shape, you should not assume that your man will react to criticism the same way you might. Some of us are simpler creatures and respond to much simpler motivations. I had a friend in graduate school whose wife said once during sex, "You're kinda squishing me and making it hard for me to breath." He promptly lost about 80 lbs and has been very fit ever since.

    I told my husband that and he said "Oh Well" !!! :laugh:
  • MzNiz
    MzNiz Posts: 20 Member
    Options
    Better to drop subtle hints to her. "Hey babe, I'm headed over to the gym. I'd love it if you joined me" Etc etc.

    Yes this. Find ways to be more active together. Hopefully it works and you both get the results you are looking for. Also, sex can burn a lot of calories, and what is wrong with more sex.
  • msprouse8
    msprouse8 Posts: 85 Member
    Options
    Jus don't give her a "membership" to a gym for Christmas like mine did to me about 8 years ago....SO not cool.
  • misteranonymous
    Options
    Thanks everyone. I appreciate that some of you were able to see that I do, in fact, love my wife very much and appreciate all of the many wonderful things about her. I was asking about a very small detail in our life together, kind of like someone noticing a leaf blower in the distance on a beautiful, peaceful, quiet summer day. It doesn't mean they aren't having the time of their life. I chose this forum of discussion because I felt it would be a way to get some meaningful, anonymous feedback with zero chance of hurting my wife's feelings. Don't forget, none of you know the first thing about either one of us other than the abstracted details that I shared. At the same time, I take no offense at those of you who assumed I was just another pig. It's natural, especially in this setting, and I intentionally hid all personal details that might have cast me in a more complimentary light.

    Really? Because I don't like hating people, so maybe you should put yourself in a more complementary light....
    It's okay. You can hate me. After all, I'm just a picture of a guy with a paper bag over his head and a cowardly use name. Just don't assume that anyone you actually know has any of the same negative traits that you ascribe to me. They probably don't.
  • raven3lise
    raven3lise Posts: 107 Member
    Options
    I didn't read all that, I'm just here as comic relief.

    But in reply to the title question:
    NOPE.jpg
  • katierechgomez
    Options
    Whatever you say, you'll be wanting to unsay, and you'll never be able to.

    This is the truth. My husband could have written this; I know he feels the same way. Most of the time he keeps his mouth shut; when he gets frustrated and says something it hurts my feelings and the relationship. It's hard to settle back in to a good sex life when I know we are both internally criticizing my body. I feel bad for him and think his disappointment is legitimate, and would like to be thin for a million reasons--he is just one of them--but I haven't been able to get it together yet. It's about being ridiculously busy, eating for reasons other than hunger, some lack of consistency re: exercise, and the fact that my husband likes to eat and keeps food that's hard for me in the house and doesn't wish to change his lifestyle in any way. Not excuses, just reasons, and ones I am still working on. Our extra pounds are probably not fair to you fitter partners in the marriage, but saying something to her won't change her body or her attitude if she's not ready to make the change but it will change the dynamic between you. Just the truth in my house.


    I completely agree with this^^ Perfectly said!!
  • nikinyx6
    nikinyx6 Posts: 772 Member
    Options
    Just tell her want the both of you to be healthy. hikes, bike rides, even just nice walks. Don't expect to bring this up then just sit idly while she works out, you'll need to be involved too
  • vvanm
    vvanm Posts: 157
    Options
    Absolutely. Your wife is probably taking care of everyone but herself. After raising 3 kids that is a natural evolution as a wife and mother. If you can help her workload, allow her time for pampering herself, take her shopping, and basically do everything in your power to help her thrive I bet the weight will come off as a byproduct. You won't have to mention anything about her not being perfect in your eyes.
  • kaseysospacey
    kaseysospacey Posts: 499 Member
    Options
    No. No, a thousand no. One comment can leave her forever feeling unattractive. BUT, you can encourage fun, physical activities and trying healthy new foods.
  • RaceyKay
    RaceyKay Posts: 6 Member
    Options
    I know that if she knew how you felt she would want to handle it. My husband asked me if I had been on the roof one morning - I said no why and he thought I had jumped from the roof to get into the jeans I was wearing - actually I thought it was pretty cute, however I was actually in denial that I needed bigger jeans and refused to buy them. I got right on taking a look at my food decisions and exercise. I ended up losing weight then he had the audacity to ask why I was looking so hot??!!
  • fatgirlanamaria
    Options
    No offense, but you are ignorant and naive. Your wife is in her 40's now, there is no way you can expect her to look the way she did when she was in her 20's. As you should already know, our metabolisms slow down as we get older, so its quite understandable that she is 30 lbs heavier now than she used to be. You should be happy that she's only 30 lbs heavier, not 50 or 100! From the way you describe her body, she does not even sound fat. She sounds quite slim, just thicker on the lower half of her body. It sounds to me like she is a "pear" shaped woman, and when she was in her 20's, she was as slim as humanly possible and was able to keep a proportionate figure, but now that her metabolism has slowed down her true shape is starting to show. Carrying extra weight on her bottom half does not mean she is fat--that's just the way her body is built. How about you stop comparing your wife to other women and accept her for who she is? If she were overweight or obese, perhaps you'd have a right to feel this way, but the fact that she is still in good shape and works out 4 times a week really makes you sound like a jerk. Stop watching porn and looking at 20 year olds and then you will come to realize that your wife is quite hot just the way she is.

    And no, there is NEVER a polite way to tell a woman she is overweight. Do you think fat people are blind or delusional? I'm sure some of them are, but most overweight people are very well aware of their weight problems and do not need to be reminded. As other people have already mentioned, someone has to want to lose weight for THEMSELVES not for their partner. Even if she lost weight because you wanted her to, she would resent you deep down, and she'd most likely gain all the weight back afterwards because she did it without motivation from within. She needs to have the desire to change for HERSELF or else the results won't be long term.
  • stang_girl88
    stang_girl88 Posts: 234 Member
    Options
    Ask her if she wants to go for walks with you. Pack up the kids and go for a walk. It may get the ball rolling. Or you could say I love you , but I can see life is wearing on you. I want you to be here forever blah blah blah and reassure her you are still attracted to her. Or do you watch the weight loss shows on TV? See her reaction to them and start asking her questions about the topic at the moment. Its all I got lol.

    P.S. If my hubs said something to me in a decent way (not hey, you're getting fat!) I would not take it personally. So take my advice with caution :wink: Good luck!
  • bushidowoman
    bushidowoman Posts: 1,599 Member
    Options
    I really appreciate the comments. I would never want to do anything that would hurt her. The truth is that she is pretty fit. She runs, cycles, lifts weights and generally probably works out 4-5 times a week. I know, the more I praise her wonderful qualities, the more I realize that I just need to count my blessings, appreciate the good things (not the least of which is peace in our relationship) and not say anything. She's talked about training to do a triathlon together. Maybe I should just focus on that.
    So you are married to a woman in her 40s who is "beautiful, intelligent, sexy, blah blah blah", who is fit and works out 4-5 times a week...and you are looking at other toned women wishing your wife looked more like ~that~?
    (Are any of these other women also in their 40s or are they young enough to be your daughters?)

    Count your blessings. Focus on the good things in your relationship. Be grateful that she puts up with you. There are probably a few other guys out there looking at her and wishing that their wives looked like ~her~.
  • David___D
    David___D Posts: 76 Member
    Options
    I asked a very similar question on this board yesterday, and it is great to read some of the replies on this questions.

    Thanks to all!

    http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/723320-persuading-spouses