14.5 bmi is this too low?
Replies
-
trigden1991 wrote: »Then why say it? Why include it in your advice?
If this was your kid wouldn't you be livid if anyone said anything to reinforce that it could possibly be OK to be concerned about bodyfat at a dangerously low BMI ?
I would be.
Apologies. His doctor told him he could damage his body by adding calories and fats too quickly. He should definitely add on weight.
Body fat percentage is different than BMI. I found a body fat percentage chart in this article:
http://www.builtlean.com/2010/08/03/ideal-body-fat-percentage-chart/
Healthy body fat range for him would be between 8-19% body fat.
He is severely under-weight so bodyfat is not the concern here.
I think that he wants to build muscle is all I am saying. He needs to gain weight. That is a given. Will you P.M. him to help find out his objectives? BMI under 18 is dangerous, correct? I don't think that he is eating enough to meet TDEE. He is seeing doctor after Christmas, so maybe he can give him a regime.
His p-ratio is extremely positive for muscle building at his BF% so even if he doesn't touch a weight he will gained a good portion of his weight in muscle.1 -
Wheelhouse15 wrote: »trigden1991 wrote: »Then why say it? Why include it in your advice?
If this was your kid wouldn't you be livid if anyone said anything to reinforce that it could possibly be OK to be concerned about bodyfat at a dangerously low BMI ?
I would be.
Apologies. His doctor told him he could damage his body by adding calories and fats too quickly. He should definitely add on weight.
Body fat percentage is different than BMI. I found a body fat percentage chart in this article:
http://www.builtlean.com/2010/08/03/ideal-body-fat-percentage-chart/
Healthy body fat range for him would be between 8-19% body fat.
He is severely under-weight so bodyfat is not the concern here.
I think that he wants to build muscle is all I am saying. He needs to gain weight. That is a given. Will you P.M. him to help find out his objectives? BMI under 18 is dangerous, correct? I don't think that he is eating enough to meet TDEE. He is seeing doctor after Christmas, so maybe he can give him a regime.
His p-ratio is extremely positive for muscle building at his BF% so even if he doesn't touch a weight he will gained a good portion of his weight in muscle.
I think that he will do great! He has a lot of potential. You have a lot of knowledge on this subject.
ETA: Here are some helpful ideas for gaining weight:
http://www.nhs.uk/Livewell/Goodfood/Pages/Underweightadults.aspx
OP, definitely stay under doctor supervision and keep getting vitals and blood checked.
0 -
Wheelhouse15 wrote: »trigden1991 wrote: »Then why say it? Why include it in your advice?
If this was your kid wouldn't you be livid if anyone said anything to reinforce that it could possibly be OK to be concerned about bodyfat at a dangerously low BMI ?
I would be.
Apologies. His doctor told him he could damage his body by adding calories and fats too quickly. He should definitely add on weight.
Body fat percentage is different than BMI. I found a body fat percentage chart in this article:
http://www.builtlean.com/2010/08/03/ideal-body-fat-percentage-chart/
Healthy body fat range for him would be between 8-19% body fat.
He is severely under-weight so bodyfat is not the concern here.
I think that he wants to build muscle is all I am saying. He needs to gain weight. That is a given. Will you P.M. him to help find out his objectives? BMI under 18 is dangerous, correct? I don't think that he is eating enough to meet TDEE. He is seeing doctor after Christmas, so maybe he can give him a regime.
His p-ratio is extremely positive for muscle building at his BF% so even if he doesn't touch a weight he will gained a good portion of his weight in muscle.
I think that he will do great! He has a lot of potential. You have a lot of knowledge on this subject.
Hopefully the OP will show up in the Weight Gain section where there are a lot of knowledgeable posters who can help him.1 -
My advice...follow what your doctor is telling you. I think too much advice from too many people can lead to information over-load when first trying to correct health issues. Once you have things under control somewhat and have a base core of knowledge then seek help from experienced people to reach your long term goals.
When I first started here at this site I read comments and then went and researched for myself.
For the short-term...listen to your doctor.4 -
My advice...follow what your doctor is telling you. I think too much advice from too many people can lead to information over-load when first trying to correct health issues. Once you have things under control somewhat and have a base core of knowledge then seek help from experienced people to reach your long term goals.
When I first started here at this site I read comments and then went and researched for myself.
For the short-term...listen to your doctor.
Good advice!0 -
I am trying to eat more but I think I might have a slight lactose intolerance as I eat cereal for breakfast and when I'm at work I feel a bit bloated and gassy. Im trying to get myself into a routine of eating and gym as the two lend to each other I'm just finding really hard to get to that point0
-
Nothing came up in the second set of blood tests so now I've gotta have a chest x-ray but I don't know what their looking for0
-
Rogue my friend: more food till you start gaining weight and get above a bmi of 20. Then we can talk about being concerned whether you're adding fat or muscle. And as someone mentioned, given your age, a good part of any weight you put on will be muscle regardless of whether you hit the gym. Not to mention that your work involves lifting things.... So .. eat more and worry about the gym less.12
-
You're young OP, take advantage of being able to eat lots and get away with it, because it wont last forever.1
-
RogueDeer5 wrote: »I am trying to eat more but I think I might have a slight lactose intolerance as I eat cereal for breakfast and when I'm at work I feel a bit bloated and gassy. Im trying to get myself into a routine of eating and gym as the two lend to each other I'm just finding really hard to get to that point
So eat things that have no lactose. Get some nuts, some nut butter, easy high calorie foods to take in. Have you gained any weight at all since you started this thread?5 -
Christine_72 wrote: »You're young OP, take advantage of being able to eat lots and get away with it, because it wont last forever.
Those were the days, my friend. People told me about it when I was in my 20s, but I didn't believe them because I was too busy burning off calories. Lol.1 -
Christine_72 wrote: »You're young OP, take advantage of being able to eat lots and get away with it, because it wont last forever.
Those were the days, my friend. People told me about it when I was in my 20s, but I didn't believe them because I was too busy burning off calories. Lol.
but he doesnt eat lots that is the problem5 -
I read you think you may be lactose intolerant? Unfortunately it is more likely to be casein intolerant, its far more common than people think, we out number those who are lactose intolerant. I find using goat milk products suit me better. Casein comes in 4 variants, normal bovine, cow is predominantly type 1. Goat is predominantly type 2. There are also types 3 and 4, these are common to most milk and do not seem to be in large enough amounts to cause problems. There is also A2 milk, which is cow but it has dominant type 2 casein defined by testing. If you try goat or A2 milk you could find you feel better, and were there lactose issues as well these would probably subside because the body is not under so much digestive pressure.0
-
Christine_72 wrote: »You're young OP, take advantage of being able to eat lots and get away with it, because it wont last forever.
Those were the days, my friend. People told me about it when I was in my 20s, but I didn't believe them because I was too busy burning off calories. Lol.
PLEASE STOP
You keep posting positively about weight loss and calorie burns on a thread where is it wholly inappropriate
Take some of your maternal instinct and use it appropriately to support a young man who needs weight GAIN support
This young man is severely underweight and clearly struggling emotionally with increasing his calories
Think before you post ..please27 -
RogueDeer5 wrote: »I am trying to eat more but I think I might have a slight lactose intolerance as I eat cereal for breakfast and when I'm at work I feel a bit bloated and gassy. Im trying to get myself into a routine of eating and gym as the two lend to each other I'm just finding really hard to get to that point
Small and often and highly dense calories
Nuts, sweets, crisps, chips anything you can think of to get your weight up1 -
^Yes. Also:
Work your way up. You won't be able to stuff your face from one day to another, you'll just get full and nauseous. Slowly increase your food intake over time.4 -
How are you with mince pies? These are small, calorie dense and everywhere so you can happily swipe a few from communal boxes as and when and that will help over the next couple of weeks at least!2
-
RogueDeer5 wrote: »I am trying to eat more but I think I might have a slight lactose intolerance as I eat cereal for breakfast and when I'm at work I feel a bit bloated and gassy. Im trying to get myself into a routine of eating and gym as the two lend to each other I'm just finding really hard to get to that point
Could it be the gluten? A celiac often ends up malnourished and overly thin because their intestinal wall is damaged and they can not absorb nutrients well. It also causes lactose intolerance in most too.
Just an idea. Good luck.0 -
RogueDeer5 wrote: »Nothing came up in the second set of blood tests so now I've gotta have a chest x-ray but I don't know what their looking for
he's probably looking at several things, but walking pneumonia would be one that would explain sudden weight loss with few other symptoms and would show up on a chest x-ray
it can be really frustrating to be constantly sent for tests and more tests and more tests, but the doctor will try to rule out the most likely causes first, so multiple rounds of testing are pretty common in my experience
hang in there and keep eating more!2 -
RogueDeer5 wrote: »I am trying to eat more but I think I might have a slight lactose intolerance as I eat cereal for breakfast and when I'm at work I feel a bit bloated and gassy. Im trying to get myself into a routine of eating and gym as the two lend to each other I'm just finding really hard to get to that point
Could it be the gluten? A celiac often ends up malnourished and overly thin because their intestinal wall is damaged and they can not absorb nutrients well. It also causes lactose intolerance in most too.
Just an idea. Good luck.
That's what I was wondering also.0 -
Christine_72 wrote: »You're young OP, take advantage of being able to eat lots and get away with it, because it wont last forever.
Those were the days, my friend. People told me about it when I was in my 20s, but I didn't believe them because I was too busy burning off calories. Lol.
PLEASE STOP
You keep posting positively about weight loss and calorie burns on a thread where is it wholly inappropriate
Take some of your maternal instinct and use it appropriately to support a young man who needs weight GAIN support
This young man is severely underweight and clearly struggling emotionally with increasing his calories
Think before you post ..please
His physician will decide. You are blowing this out of proportion. The poster I was replying to was simply saying to him to enjoy eating a lot now while he can.2 -
RogueDeer5 wrote: »Had my appointment today it was with my family Dr who hasn't seen me in years so he went over my entire medical history and he was concerned about my weight but the blood test came up clear so he booked me in for another blood test...
He said that I should try eating some more healthy fats and protein from things like milk and cheese but don't just start eating loads as it could damage my body with the sudden increase in calories and fats and as I go to the gym a bit doing weight training he told me to eat more protein and I will bulk up a bit and also to start cardio exercises to make sure I'm keeping my heart healthy
Then he said he wants to keep an eye on me so after the blood test I have to see him but he said it will most likely not be till after Christmas.
The bodybuilders on MFP can show you how to eat enough to build muscle during weight training. The thing is you will need to eat more to bulk up while training. Otherwise it will be difficult for your body to build muscle while in your current calorie deficit. (I'm not sure what an ideal, healthy, body fat percentage range for a man your age is. I remember seeing a chart somewhere that showed that.)
It sounds to me like you have very active life. Cardio will burn calories so be careful to eat extra while doing those kinds of exercises. I have a feeling you will get the information you need. There is a learning curve, so definitely keep researching and don't give up.
... It takes some planning to make sure that you get enough calories. But an easy way to do that is to get in enough fats and upping your protein like your doctor said. It's great to hear that you were able to get in to see the doctor and hope your second set of blood tests scheduled to be taken after Christmas show normal also.
...It sounds like you are an active person and are simply not eating as much as you are burning. You are wise that you with checked with your physician before embarking on changing up your diet. At least now that you are doctor supervised, he is giving you helpful advice on how to slowly build up your muscle mass and is watching out for you.
Don't forget that there is a gaining weight forum on MFP where you might get other ideas from people experiencing similar difficulty gaining.
This is the advice I gave.1 -
RogueDeer5 wrote: »I am trying to eat more but I think I might have a slight lactose intolerance as I eat cereal for breakfast and when I'm at work I feel a bit bloated and gassy. Im trying to get myself into a routine of eating and gym as the two lend to each other I'm just finding really hard to get to that point
What foods do you like? Whatever it is...eat larger portions of those foods.
If cereal and milk leave you bloated and gassy...don't eat cereal and milk. You don't have to eat breakfast food for breakfast. If you like pizza...eat a slice or two for breakfast. Pasta with meat sauce can taste pretty good in the morning too. My favorite breakfast...peanut butter sandwich with a banana and a squirt or two of honey.
If you can't eat a large quantity of food at a time...try eating smaller portions more often.
My point is...take the things that you like to eat...and eat more of it. Either increase the size of your portions or eat more frequently.
One last thing...don't worry whether you are lactose intolerant right now. Let the doctor figure out why you are so thin first and then he can do some further testing on any other concerns that you have right now.
Just focus on your eating...there will be time later for the rest of the things such as the gym. Don't try to do it all at once.6 -
Christine_72 wrote: »You're young OP, take advantage of being able to eat lots and get away with it, because it wont last forever.
Those were the days, my friend. People told me about it when I was in my 20s, but I didn't believe them because I was too busy burning off calories. Lol.
PLEASE STOP
You keep posting positively about weight loss and calorie burns on a thread where is it wholly inappropriate
Take some of your maternal instinct and use it appropriately to support a young man who needs weight GAIN support
This young man is severely underweight and clearly struggling emotionally with increasing his calories
Think before you post ..please
His physician will decide. You are blowing this out of proportion. The poster I was replying to was simply saying to him to enjoy eating a lot now while he can.
Think about the situation he's in. He's telling us about how a bowl of cereal hurts his stomach maybe because of the milk, whereas most of us in his situation would ecstatically have an awesome story about the new FULL PINT of (lactose free?) icecream we've eaten everyday since we were confronted with our situation. Ever wonder why that is? I don't know that he has any kind of severe condition, but it seems quite plain to me that he doesn't love to eat. Don't glamorize or trivialize what you were, here; he doesn't need this.5 -
Christine_72 wrote: »You're young OP, take advantage of being able to eat lots and get away with it, because it wont last forever.
Those were the days, my friend. People told me about it when I was in my 20s, but I didn't believe them because I was too busy burning off calories. Lol.
PLEASE STOP
You keep posting positively about weight loss and calorie burns on a thread where is it wholly inappropriate
Take some of your maternal instinct and use it appropriately to support a young man who needs weight GAIN support
This young man is severely underweight and clearly struggling emotionally with increasing his calories
Think before you post ..please
His physician will decide. You are blowing this out of proportion. The poster I was replying to was simply saying to him to enjoy eating a lot now while he can.
Think about the situation he's in. He's telling us about how a bowl of cereal hurts his stomach maybe because of the milk, whereas most of us in his situation would ecstatically have an awesome story about the new FULL PINT of (lactose free?) icecream we've eaten everyday since we were confronted with our situation. Ever wonder why that is? I don't know that he has any kind of severe condition, but it seems quite plain to me that he doesn't love to eat. Don't glamorize or trivialize what you were, here; he doesn't need this.
Are you kidding me? I definitely am not trivializing. He is seeing a doctor. Yes he should ask about possible lactose intolerance and possible celiac. He will see a doctor after Christmas. Of course I am not glamorizing being thin. I'm trying to encourage OP to gain weight also.1 -
Christine_72 wrote: »You're young OP, take advantage of being able to eat lots and get away with it, because it wont last forever.
Those were the days, my friend. People told me about it when I was in my 20s, but I didn't believe them because I was too busy burning off calories. Lol.
PLEASE STOP
You keep posting positively about weight loss and calorie burns on a thread where is it wholly inappropriate
Take some of your maternal instinct and use it appropriately to support a young man who needs weight GAIN support
This young man is severely underweight and clearly struggling emotionally with increasing his calories
Think before you post ..please
His physician will decide. You are blowing this out of proportion. The poster I was replying to was simply saying to him to enjoy eating a lot now while he can.
Think about the situation he's in. He's telling us about how a bowl of cereal hurts his stomach maybe because of the milk, whereas most of us in his situation would ecstatically have an awesome story about the new FULL PINT of (lactose free?) icecream we've eaten everyday since we were confronted with our situation. Ever wonder why that is? I don't know that he has any kind of severe condition, but it seems quite plain to me that he doesn't love to eat. Don't glamorize or trivialize what you were, here; he doesn't need this.
I agree. He also doesn't need other diseases thrown out for him to think he might have.
He is only 20y/o...lacks nutritional knowledge...has a problem with eating enough. That should be his primary concern at this point. If his doctor is concerned about anything else...he will do the testing. Just no sense in throwing something else out there for him to use as an excuse for him not to eat.
I know that people are trying to be helpful but it could backfire and make things worse. We don't know if this young man is dealing with an eating disorder or if there is something actually physically wrong with him or not.10 -
I think he's just ruling out any underlying medical issues thoroughly so that if it is just a case of not eating enough (and by your own admission you find eating tough) then he can come down hard on working out a strategy to get you eating more.
but I think you need to work on this as a priority because regardless of any health issues you are simply not eating enough full stop. Even if something is discovered it would still require you to adequately nourish your body so may as well start working on it right now.
As someone said, this time of year is perfect, there are plenty of calorie dense treats and options. Even the seasonal special sandwiches are bigger calorie bombs than the usual. Full sugar drinks. Add a packet of crisps and a bar of chocolate to each meal, low volume but high calorie, easy ways to up your intake. Have a little baggy of nuts in your pocket at all times to graze on. Get those little snack size cheese portions and grab one every time you're near the fridge. Little things like that will go a long way to increasing intake.4 -
Christine_72 wrote: »You're young OP, take advantage of being able to eat lots and get away with it, because it wont last forever.
C'mon guys, I was the one that said this... @DebSozo was just agreeing with me, she shouldn't be the one to get "told off" because of my comment.6 -
Seriously. This OP is a full grown man. He isn't underage. He is intelligent and is actually listening to people about going to the doctor for screening before going forward with a plan to gain weight. Sheesh.1
-
Seriously. This OP is a full grown man. He isn't underage. He is intelligent and is actually listening to people about going to the doctor for screening before going forward with a plan to gain weight. Sheesh.
I actually disagree. OP showed little effort to actually get into the doctor and made excuses for several pages before he actually did. He has been resistant to eating more. The line of questioning from the doctor suggests the doctor thinks an ED is a possibility.9
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 422 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions