Coronavirus prep
Replies
-
In passenger seat and skipped over much of above, but will go back later. I will describe the experience of good friends which I do find concerning.
Husband got his second Moderna shot. That night, he got sick. You can debate whether related or not. Description used words like paralysis, but nurse wife ultimately labeled if seizure. Brought to er and admitted. Tests done. Wife asked for antibody assessment several times, out of concern of vaccine reaction. Was refused. Was told no proof of causality and “not on list”. IMO if one never examines an oddly timed illness for consideration of association, then how does it ever get on the list. And if only items on the list get considered, then new problems are never identified. Anyhow, assuming this was all described to me accurately, I find it concerning and makes me wonder about all kinds on claims.
Quick edit: this gentleman also had confirmed COVID Xmas 2020.4 -
missysippy930 wrote: »Just a little context on cause of death. My oldest sister had a double mastectomy at 38. At 54 she was diagnosed with lung, brain and adrenal cancer. Six weeks later, less than a week before radiation treatment for the brain cancer was going to begin, she died from pneumonia. Pneumonia was the official cause of death, but, the cancers, weakened her system.
Not related to the above. As far as the 3rd shot for covid goes, my husband was hospitalized in late May for 5 days. Blood clots in his knee area traveled to his lungs. We had our second Moderna shot in April. No family history of blood clots. The doctor did ask if we had the vaccine and said there could be a small risk factor for blood clots as a side effect. He’s been on Xarelto since then. How can you make a decision whether or not to get the 3rd shot, not knowing if the vaccine may have caused the blood clots? From what I understand, we would be eligible around December. No one knows for sure. Ultimately, a very personal decision.
What you described us pretty much where my head is at. I am pro immunity and pro vaccination. I am struggling some with forcing booster shots and even struggling with forcing vaccination for those with “natural immunity”.
4 -
ExistingFish wrote: »rheddmobile wrote: »rheddmobile wrote: »ExistingFish wrote: »I personally know no one in my life who has died from covid.
I have personal connections to two people who died from the covid vaccine.
Please be respectful of this when pushing the vaccine or denigrating those who choose not to take it.
The thing is, I don’t believe you, because so few people around the world have died following the vaccine that for a single person to know two of them is astronomically unlikely.
Exactly!
Not comfortable with calling each other liars here. We may have differing opinions, but I go in with the premise that, especially when people are making personal statements, they are telling the truth.
I try to give people the benefit of the doubt, but in this case, what is claimed is not possible.
This sort of deliberate misinformation is killing real people in the real world. Responsible social media forums are deleting it.
These were aquaintances, not close friends.
The first was very concerned about covid, he stayed home all year. Went out as soon as he was able to get vaccinated. He had a heart attack within 24 hours. I don't know his family history, but these vaccines do cause increased risk for heart attack.
The second, I don't know her cause of death - coworker of a family member. She was out already for knee surgery, so she was not in peak health. Sick in bed for a week, died. I don't know if she got an infection or something - but everyone in her life said she died as a result of the vaccine.
Many people do die of heart attacks. many people have vaccines.
It stands to reason that some people will have a heart attack 24 hours after having a vaccine - in fact would be statistically impossible for this not to happen, given the frequency of both events.
Likewise people have heart attacks within 24 hours of having a roast dinner or going to a football game or playing Scrabble - needless to say, one event did not cause the other.
18 -
MargaretYakoda wrote: »ExistingFish wrote: »Giulia Lucenti - 16 yr - Pfizer
Rosette Kyarikunda - med student - AZ
James Cooper - 77 yrs - death from 3rd shot (booster)
Mahima Mathew - 31 - AZ
Kim Jarvis - 57 yrs - death in sleep within 24 hours
These are just from September, just found with a quick search.
I can very easily put up a WordPress site and make it say owning dogs makes people die in car accidents.
Doesn’t mean anything.
Is it really on WordPress?
/runs off/
Why yes, yes it is. LMAO.13 -
Alabama man dies after being turned away from 43 hospitals as Covid packs ICUs, family says
When Ray DeMonia was having a cardiac emergency last month, his Alabama family waited anxiously for a nearby hospital with available space in its intensive care unit.
But in a state where coronavirus infections and unvaccinated patients have overwhelmed hospitals in recent months, finding an available ICU bed was an ordeal. It was so difficult, his family wrote this month, that the hospital in his hometown of Cullman, Ala., contacted 43 others in three states — and all were unable to give him the care he needed.
DeMonia, who was eventually transferred to a Mississippi hospital about 200 miles away, died at 73 on Sept. 1 — three days shy of his birthday.
Raven DeMonia, his daughter, told The Washington Post on Sunday that it was “shocking” when the family was told that dozens of ICUs were unable to treat her father.
“It was like, ‘What do you mean?’ ” she said when she found out her father was being airlifted to a Mississippi hospital. “I never thought this would happen to us.”
Now, in DeMonia’s obituary, his family is urging those who remain unvaccinated to get immunized to help hospitals that have been pushed to their limits and struggling to treat emergencies not related to the pandemic. His daughter told The Post he was vaccinated against the coronavirus.
“In honor of Ray, please get vaccinated if you have not, in an effort to free up resources for non COVID related emergencies,” the family wrote. “He would not want any other family to go through what his did.”16 -
kshama2001 wrote: »Alabama man dies after being turned away from 43 hospitals as Covid packs ICUs, family says
When Ray DeMonia was having a cardiac emergency last month, his Alabama family waited anxiously for a nearby hospital with available space in its intensive care unit.
But in a state where coronavirus infections and unvaccinated patients have overwhelmed hospitals in recent months, finding an available ICU bed was an ordeal. It was so difficult, his family wrote this month, that the hospital in his hometown of Cullman, Ala., contacted 43 others in three states — and all were unable to give him the care he needed.
DeMonia, who was eventually transferred to a Mississippi hospital about 200 miles away, died at 73 on Sept. 1 — three days shy of his birthday.
Raven DeMonia, his daughter, told The Washington Post on Sunday that it was “shocking” when the family was told that dozens of ICUs were unable to treat her father.
“It was like, ‘What do you mean?’ ” she said when she found out her father was being airlifted to a Mississippi hospital. “I never thought this would happen to us.”
Now, in DeMonia’s obituary, his family is urging those who remain unvaccinated to get immunized to help hospitals that have been pushed to their limits and struggling to treat emergencies not related to the pandemic. His daughter told The Post he was vaccinated against the coronavirus.
“In honor of Ray, please get vaccinated if you have not, in an effort to free up resources for non COVID related emergencies,” the family wrote. “He would not want any other family to go through what his did.”
And another one.
A Texas veteran in his 40’s. Got a gall stone with a complication. No beds. So he died.
https://www.cbsnews.com/amp/news/covid-us-hospital-icu-bed-shortage-veteran-dies-treatable-illness/9 -
In passenger seat and skipped over much of above, but will go back later. I will describe the experience of good friends which I do find concerning.
Husband got his second Moderna shot. That night, he got sick. You can debate whether related or not. Description used words like paralysis, but nurse wife ultimately labeled if seizure. Brought to er and admitted. Tests done. Wife asked for antibody assessment several times, out of concern of vaccine reaction. Was refused. Was told no proof of causality and “not on list”. IMO if one never examines an oddly timed illness for consideration of association, then how does it ever get on the list. And if only items on the list get considered, then new problems are never identified. Anyhow, assuming this was all described to me accurately, I find it concerning and makes me wonder about all kinds on claims.
Quick edit: this gentleman also had confirmed COVID Xmas 2020.
If he had the vaccine recently, you would expect him to have antibodies. How would that remotely qualify as evidence that the vaccination caused the stroke?9 -
MargaretYakoda wrote: »ExistingFish wrote: »Giulia Lucenti - 16 yr - Pfizer
Rosette Kyarikunda - med student - AZ
James Cooper - 77 yrs - death from 3rd shot (booster)
Mahima Mathew - 31 - AZ
Kim Jarvis - 57 yrs - death in sleep within 24 hours
These are just from September, just found with a quick search.
I can very easily put up a WordPress site and make it say owning dogs makes people die in car accidents.
Doesn’t mean anything.
Giulia - https://www.italy24news.com/covid-19/182545.html
Rosettte - https://campusbee.ug/news/final-year-medical-student-dies-from-allegedly-covid-19-jab-related-side-effects/
(August 31st, 2021 date of death)
Mahima - https://www.ibtimes.com/hospital-links-pregnant-womans-death-covid-19-vaccine-3279476
(August 20th, 2021 date of death)
Unfortunately the other two names were far too common, do you know how many "Kim Jarvis" there are on LinkedIn? I do now.2 -
lynn_glenmont wrote: »In passenger seat and skipped over much of above, but will go back later. I will describe the experience of good friends which I do find concerning.
Husband got his second Moderna shot. That night, he got sick. You can debate whether related or not. Description used words like paralysis, but nurse wife ultimately labeled if seizure. Brought to er and admitted. Tests done. Wife asked for antibody assessment several times, out of concern of vaccine reaction. Was refused. Was told no proof of causality and “not on list”. IMO if one never examines an oddly timed illness for consideration of association, then how does it ever get on the list. And if only items on the list get considered, then new problems are never identified. Anyhow, assuming this was all described to me accurately, I find it concerning and makes me wonder about all kinds on claims.
Quick edit: this gentleman also had confirmed COVID Xmas 2020.
If he had the vaccine recently, you would expect him to have antibodies. How would that remotely qualify as evidence that the vaccination caused the stroke?
Blood clots are one of the known and recognized side effects of these vaccines, some manufacturers more than others. Don't act like it's so far outside the realm of possibility.6 -
@ExistingFish Blood clots are also a symptom of Covid and at a much higher rate than the vaccine. All vaccines have side effects for some subset of the population. On the whole the symptoms of Covid are far more serious than the vaccines.
I had the shingles vaccine a month ago and it caused some weird redness near the injection site as well as some tingling side effects. A month later that redness has faded into a "tan line" which makes me apprehensive about the second shot. I'll still get it because I've had friends who had shingles and I don't want it.
Life is full of calculated risks. I'm fully vaccinated and in spite of some minor concerns I decided I would much rather take the chance with the vaccine than Covid itself. Others may feel differently. However, if I have a serious health issue or get in an accident that requires immediate attention I would not be very happy that the ER is not able to accommodate me because the hospital is full of people who chose not to be vaccinated. If the non-vaccinated are so convinced they are on the right path then perhaps they should stay the *kitten* away from hospitals.18 -
ExistingFish wrote: »lynn_glenmont wrote: »In passenger seat and skipped over much of above, but will go back later. I will describe the experience of good friends which I do find concerning.
Husband got his second Moderna shot. That night, he got sick. You can debate whether related or not. Description used words like paralysis, but nurse wife ultimately labeled if seizure. Brought to er and admitted. Tests done. Wife asked for antibody assessment several times, out of concern of vaccine reaction. Was refused. Was told no proof of causality and “not on list”. IMO if one never examines an oddly timed illness for consideration of association, then how does it ever get on the list. And if only items on the list get considered, then new problems are never identified. Anyhow, assuming this was all described to me accurately, I find it concerning and makes me wonder about all kinds on claims.
Quick edit: this gentleman also had confirmed COVID Xmas 2020.
If he had the vaccine recently, you would expect him to have antibodies. How would that remotely qualify as evidence that the vaccination caused the stroke?
Blood clots are one of the known and recognized side effects of these vaccines, some manufacturers more than others. Don't act like it's so far outside the realm of possibility.
Blood clots also just happen sometimes.
One person having a blood clot after a vaccine means nothing.6 -
ExistingFish wrote: »MargaretYakoda wrote: »ExistingFish wrote: »Giulia Lucenti - 16 yr - Pfizer
Rosette Kyarikunda - med student - AZ
James Cooper - 77 yrs - death from 3rd shot (booster)
Mahima Mathew - 31 - AZ
Kim Jarvis - 57 yrs - death in sleep within 24 hours
These are just from September, just found with a quick search.
I can very easily put up a WordPress site and make it say owning dogs makes people die in car accidents.
Doesn’t mean anything.
Giulia - https://www.italy24news.com/covid-19/182545.html
Rosettte - https://campusbee.ug/news/final-year-medical-student-dies-from-allegedly-covid-19-jab-related-side-effects/
(August 31st, 2021 date of death)
Mahima - https://www.ibtimes.com/hospital-links-pregnant-womans-death-covid-19-vaccine-3279476
(August 20th, 2021 date of death)
Unfortunately the other two names were far too common, do you know how many "Kim Jarvis" there are on LinkedIn? I do now.
Did you actually read those articles?
1) The first one says the 16 year old girl had mitral valve prolapse. My dad had the exact same thing. And it caused about eight heart attacks. One of which killed him.
I’m gonna say this wasn’t the vaccine. Which is the view of her parents.
2) This one has “allegedly” right in the headline. Editing to add it is a campus newspaper, with extremely poor editing.
Hard pass.
3) No autopsy at the time the article was written. So also, hard pass.
You have so far shared zero proof that the vaccines available in North America have killed anyone.18 -
MargaretYakoda wrote: »ExistingFish wrote: »MargaretYakoda wrote: »ExistingFish wrote: »Giulia Lucenti - 16 yr - Pfizer
Rosette Kyarikunda - med student - AZ
James Cooper - 77 yrs - death from 3rd shot (booster)
Mahima Mathew - 31 - AZ
Kim Jarvis - 57 yrs - death in sleep within 24 hours
These are just from September, just found with a quick search.
I can very easily put up a WordPress site and make it say owning dogs makes people die in car accidents.
Doesn’t mean anything.
Giulia - https://www.italy24news.com/covid-19/182545.html
Rosettte - https://campusbee.ug/news/final-year-medical-student-dies-from-allegedly-covid-19-jab-related-side-effects/
(August 31st, 2021 date of death)
Mahima - https://www.ibtimes.com/hospital-links-pregnant-womans-death-covid-19-vaccine-3279476
(August 20th, 2021 date of death)
Unfortunately the other two names were far too common, do you know how many "Kim Jarvis" there are on LinkedIn? I do now.
Did you actually read those articles?
1) The first one says the 16 year old girl had mitral valve prolapse. My dad had the exact same thing. And it caused about eight heart attacks. One of which killed him.
I’m gonna say this wasn’t the vaccine. Which is the view of her parents.
2) This one has “allegedly” right in the headline. Editing to add it is a campus newspaper, with extremely poor editing.
Hard pass.
3) No autopsy at the time the article was written. So also, hard pass.
You have so far shared zero proof that the vaccines available in North America have killed anyone.
No good if it's on a covid blog - k, found news articles - no good for you either. Got it.
Of course it says allegedly, it isn't proven yet.
Because, 3rd - regular people don't routinely get autopsies. As stated further up in this thread, doctor's won't even put recent vaccination on a possible cause of ER admission, it isn't even being considered - so there never will be evidence because people keep denying it is even possible.2 -
So you are now moving away from ' 2 people I know' - who had the vaccine then died of things people do die of anyway to people on blog sites with unproven connections??
Have you heard of confirmation bias?17 -
paperpudding wrote: »So you are now moving away from ' 2 people I know' - who had the vaccine then died of things people do die of anyway to people on blog sites with unproven connections??
Have you heard of confirmation bias?
"You have not proof! this can't be real, people aren't dying from this so you can't know people who are dying"
"Okay, here is some quick to find proof"
"This is confirmation bias!"
You can't actually get proof because they aren't looking for it, so they won't find it. Read in this very thread posted this very day, people go to the ER within 24 hours of their vaccine with major side effects and are told it could not be because of the vaccine and it isn't recorded.5 -
ExistingFish wrote: »paperpudding wrote: »So you are now moving away from ' 2 people I know' - who had the vaccine then died of things people do die of anyway to people on blog sites with unproven connections??
Have you heard of confirmation bias?
"You have not proof! this can't be real, people aren't dying from this so you can't know people who are dying"
"Okay, here is some quick to find proof"
"This is confirmation bias!"
You can't actually get proof because they aren't looking for it, so they won't find it. Read in this very thread posted this very day, people go to the ER within 24 hours of their vaccine with major side effects and are told it could not be because of the vaccine and it isn't recorded.
I’m probably going to regret this but…
WHY would doctors break the Hippocratic oath to hide vaccine related deaths?
It makes no sense.15 -
ExistingFish wrote: »MargaretYakoda wrote: »ExistingFish wrote: »MargaretYakoda wrote: »ExistingFish wrote: »Giulia Lucenti - 16 yr - Pfizer
Rosette Kyarikunda - med student - AZ
James Cooper - 77 yrs - death from 3rd shot (booster)
Mahima Mathew - 31 - AZ
Kim Jarvis - 57 yrs - death in sleep within 24 hours
These are just from September, just found with a quick search.
I can very easily put up a WordPress site and make it say owning dogs makes people die in car accidents.
Doesn’t mean anything.
Giulia - https://www.italy24news.com/covid-19/182545.html
Rosettte - https://campusbee.ug/news/final-year-medical-student-dies-from-allegedly-covid-19-jab-related-side-effects/
(August 31st, 2021 date of death)
Mahima - https://www.ibtimes.com/hospital-links-pregnant-womans-death-covid-19-vaccine-3279476
(August 20th, 2021 date of death)
Unfortunately the other two names were far too common, do you know how many "Kim Jarvis" there are on LinkedIn? I do now.
Did you actually read those articles?
1) The first one says the 16 year old girl had mitral valve prolapse. My dad had the exact same thing. And it caused about eight heart attacks. One of which killed him.
I’m gonna say this wasn’t the vaccine. Which is the view of her parents.
2) This one has “allegedly” right in the headline. Editing to add it is a campus newspaper, with extremely poor editing.
Hard pass.
3) No autopsy at the time the article was written. So also, hard pass.
You have so far shared zero proof that the vaccines available in North America have killed anyone.
No good if it's on a covid blog - k, found news articles - no good for you either. Got it.
Of course it says allegedly, it isn't proven yet.
Because, 3rd - regular people don't routinely get autopsies. As stated further up in this thread, doctor's won't even put recent vaccination on a possible cause of ER admission, it isn't even being considered - so there never will be evidence because people keep denying it is even possible.
People suspected - by doctors, not randos - of dying of the vaccine are not regular people and do get autopsies. The Johnson and Johnson vaccine was paused while deaths suspected to be from that vaccine were invested, it’s actually a big deal and not a casual thing.21 -
ExistingFish wrote: »paperpudding wrote: »So you are now moving away from ' 2 people I know' - who had the vaccine then died of things people do die of anyway to people on blog sites with unproven connections??
Have you heard of confirmation bias?
"You have not proof! this can't be real, people aren't dying from this so you can't know people who are dying"
"Okay, here is some quick to find proof"
"This is confirmation bias!"
You can't actually get proof because they aren't looking for it, so they won't find it. Read in this very thread posted this very day, people go to the ER within 24 hours of their vaccine with major side effects and are told it could not be because of the vaccine and it isn't recorded.
Actually - No you didnt provide any quick to find proof as has been pointed out already.
Nor did you know 2 people who died from Covid vaccine as has also been pointed out.
we all have confirmation bias - that is why research does double blind and independently reviewed analysis
If one is looking for proof of something and interprets everything as being proof of that without critical thinking about the source or the information - yes that is confirmation bias
Or rather conformation bias that one has no insight or recognition of - and therefore is doing nothing to account for or to balance such.
19 -
ExistingFish wrote: »MargaretYakoda wrote: »ExistingFish wrote: »MargaretYakoda wrote: »ExistingFish wrote: »Giulia Lucenti - 16 yr - Pfizer
Rosette Kyarikunda - med student - AZ
James Cooper - 77 yrs - death from 3rd shot (booster)
Mahima Mathew - 31 - AZ
Kim Jarvis - 57 yrs - death in sleep within 24 hours
These are just from September, just found with a quick search.
I can very easily put up a WordPress site and make it say owning dogs makes people die in car accidents.
Doesn’t mean anything.
Giulia - https://www.italy24news.com/covid-19/182545.html
Rosettte - https://campusbee.ug/news/final-year-medical-student-dies-from-allegedly-covid-19-jab-related-side-effects/
(August 31st, 2021 date of death)
Mahima - https://www.ibtimes.com/hospital-links-pregnant-womans-death-covid-19-vaccine-3279476
(August 20th, 2021 date of death)
Unfortunately the other two names were far too common, do you know how many "Kim Jarvis" there are on LinkedIn? I do now.
Did you actually read those articles?
1) The first one says the 16 year old girl had mitral valve prolapse. My dad had the exact same thing. And it caused about eight heart attacks. One of which killed him.
I’m gonna say this wasn’t the vaccine. Which is the view of her parents.
2) This one has “allegedly” right in the headline. Editing to add it is a campus newspaper, with extremely poor editing.
Hard pass.
3) No autopsy at the time the article was written. So also, hard pass.
You have so far shared zero proof that the vaccines available in North America have killed anyone.
No good if it's on a covid blog - k, found news articles - no good for you either. Got it.
Of course it says allegedly, it isn't proven yet.
Because, 3rd - regular people don't routinely get autopsies. As stated further up in this thread, doctor's won't even put recent vaccination on a possible cause of ER admission, it isn't even being considered - so there never will be evidence because people keep denying it is even possible.
The first one:
I didn’t point out that it was on a COVID blog. I pointed out that the girl’s parents don’t believe her death was related to the vaccine. They believe it was related to her mitral valve prolapse.
Which can cause sudden heart attacks. Even in a 16 year old.
The reason for her death is bleeping obvious.
It’s literally exactly what my dad died of.
Mitral valve prolapse isn’t always serious. But sometimes it is deadly.
The second one: You admit it’s not proven. So why do you try to use it to prove your point?
And @rheddmobile handled the third one nicely.
13 -
lynn_glenmont wrote: »In passenger seat and skipped over much of above, but will go back later. I will describe the experience of good friends which I do find concerning.
Husband got his second Moderna shot. That night, he got sick. You can debate whether related or not. Description used words like paralysis, but nurse wife ultimately labeled if seizure. Brought to er and admitted. Tests done. Wife asked for antibody assessment several times, out of concern of vaccine reaction. Was refused. Was told no proof of causality and “not on list”. IMO if one never examines an oddly timed illness for consideration of association, then how does it ever get on the list. And if only items on the list get considered, then new problems are never identified. Anyhow, assuming this was all described to me accurately, I find it concerning and makes me wonder about all kinds on claims.
Quick edit: this gentleman also had confirmed COVID Xmas 2020.
If he had the vaccine recently, you would expect him to have antibodies. How would that remotely qualify as evidence that the vaccination caused the stroke?
Logical point. Their first dose was 3+ months after recovering and their second dose was about 5 weeks instead of 4. The thought would be to see if he was put into an excessive state of antibodies. The couple claims that they spoke with a friend who works in vaccine science and she commented that what they described was due to an overload of antibodies. I feel like the phrasing was something like an antibody storm. Apologies that this is hearsay, but these people are not anti Vaxers or anything and solely shared their experience and observations.3 -
Again, I can only speak for here in Ontario, but here they are definitely counting anyone who dies WITH covid in the official death counts in all of the major health units:
“Toronto Public Health continues to follow the provincial definition for how COVID-19 deaths are categorized,” said Dr. Vinita Dubey, Toronto’s associate medical officer of health. “This means that individuals who have died with COVID-19, but not necessarily as a result of COVID-19, are all included in the case counts for COVID-19 deaths in Toronto.”
https://torontosun.com/news/provincial/ontario-death-count-includes-people-who-didnt-die-of-covid-19-but-exactly-how-many-is-unknown
5 -
lynn_glenmont wrote: »In passenger seat and skipped over much of above, but will go back later. I will describe the experience of good friends which I do find concerning.
Husband got his second Moderna shot. That night, he got sick. You can debate whether related or not. Description used words like paralysis, but nurse wife ultimately labeled if seizure. Brought to er and admitted. Tests done. Wife asked for antibody assessment several times, out of concern of vaccine reaction. Was refused. Was told no proof of causality and “not on list”. IMO if one never examines an oddly timed illness for consideration of association, then how does it ever get on the list. And if only items on the list get considered, then new problems are never identified. Anyhow, assuming this was all described to me accurately, I find it concerning and makes me wonder about all kinds on claims.
Quick edit: this gentleman also had confirmed COVID Xmas 2020.
If he had the vaccine recently, you would expect him to have antibodies. How would that remotely qualify as evidence that the vaccination caused the stroke?
Logical point. Their first dose was 3+ months after recovering and their second dose was about 5 weeks instead of 4. The thought would be to see if he was put into an excessive state of antibodies. The couple claims that they spoke with a friend who works in vaccine science and she commented that what they described was due to an overload of antibodies. I feel like the phrasing was something like an antibody storm. Apologies that this is hearsay, but these people are not anti Vaxers or anything and solely shared their experience and observations.
With sudden paralysis immediately following vaccination or infection, they should have tested for antigangliocide antibodies to rule out Guillain-Barre. Sounds like your friend was right to ask.
It sounds like they eventually decided the subsequent course of the illness was unlike Guillain-Barre, however?
The thing about Guillain-Barre is it’s a very rare reaction which can occur in response to almost any vaccine, including generally safe and approved vaccines, because it has to do with a rare individual’s cells resembling the pathogen such that their immune system becomes confused. And - this is the important part - it is EVEN MORE LIKELY to happen to that person should they actually catch the infection. Imagine that the police department from a neighboring city sends your home town a wanted poster for a criminal who just happens to look exactly like you. The police in your city may try to arrest you by mistake if they see you. Now imagine that no poster is posted, but that criminal shows up in your home town and goes on a rampage. The police are even more likely to arrest or even shoot you by mistake.
So, if this was what caused the paralysis, your friend catching Covid would have been even more likely to cause it. In fact most cases of Guillain-Barre are caused by infections, not vaccines.
8 -
I'm a little behind on my TWIV listening, but the last epi I listened to was an interview with Dr Shane Crotty, a virologist from the La Jolla Institute of Immunology. Lots of interesting conversation in this one. What stood out to me is he said he sees a lot of variability in natural immunity markers. In other words, some folks who've had covid seem to have strong and probably long lasting immunity while others don't. He theorizes that could be down to which variant a person gets. Vaccine immunity seems more "consistent". Noted of course use of the words "seems" and "likely" and "we suspect" etc. Anyway he said he would advise anyone who had covid to get at least one dose to ensure consistent immune response, at least until they can develop a more certain understanding.11
-
ExistingFish wrote: »lynn_glenmont wrote: »In passenger seat and skipped over much of above, but will go back later. I will describe the experience of good friends which I do find concerning.
Husband got his second Moderna shot. That night, he got sick. You can debate whether related or not. Description used words like paralysis, but nurse wife ultimately labeled if seizure. Brought to er and admitted. Tests done. Wife asked for antibody assessment several times, out of concern of vaccine reaction. Was refused. Was told no proof of causality and “not on list”. IMO if one never examines an oddly timed illness for consideration of association, then how does it ever get on the list. And if only items on the list get considered, then new problems are never identified. Anyhow, assuming this was all described to me accurately, I find it concerning and makes me wonder about all kinds on claims.
Quick edit: this gentleman also had confirmed COVID Xmas 2020.
If he had the vaccine recently, you would expect him to have antibodies. How would that remotely qualify as evidence that the vaccination caused the stroke?
Blood clots are one of the known and recognized side effects of these vaccines, some manufacturers more than others. Don't act like it's so far outside the realm of possibility.
I'm not. I'm questioning what the implication of being refused an antibody test is supposed to be. There doesn't seem to be any question of whether he had the vaccine. What would screening for antibodies prove? It's irrelevant but is included in the anecdote as though it shows some malfeasance on the part of the medical team.8 -
Blood clots are aside effect of COVID.
It is now more recognised than it was, because many with covid died because of blood clots in the initial and probably middle stages of medical understanding. Even so the frequency of blood clots are many times fewer with the vaccine than with covid, early Symptoms are known now.
I expect everyone has access to the medical sheet which goes with each and every medication and vaccine. Possibly one has to ask for the one which comes with the vaccine, packets of pills and bottles have this information in the box. Every medication and vaccine has such a sheet to go along with it if you look or ask. It is possible to get one pre appointment to read pre vaccine and consider or are expected to read before taking any medication, they identify ingredients allergens and more importantly any possible and less likely side effects and symptoms and when to alert medical professionals who know so much more now than at the start of the year. We have these sheets here in the UK, I take notice and ask if necessary.12 -
here in Australia, where I give Covid vaccines to people - there is an information sheet about common and rare side effects and what to look out for and when to seek medical assistance.
Every person getting the vaccine gets the take home info sheet - and signs consent to say they have read it before getting the jab.11 -
lynn_glenmont wrote: »ExistingFish wrote: »lynn_glenmont wrote: »In passenger seat and skipped over much of above, but will go back later. I will describe the experience of good friends which I do find concerning.
Husband got his second Moderna shot. That night, he got sick. You can debate whether related or not. Description used words like paralysis, but nurse wife ultimately labeled if seizure. Brought to er and admitted. Tests done. Wife asked for antibody assessment several times, out of concern of vaccine reaction. Was refused. Was told no proof of causality and “not on list”. IMO if one never examines an oddly timed illness for consideration of association, then how does it ever get on the list. And if only items on the list get considered, then new problems are never identified. Anyhow, assuming this was all described to me accurately, I find it concerning and makes me wonder about all kinds on claims.
Quick edit: this gentleman also had confirmed COVID Xmas 2020.
If he had the vaccine recently, you would expect him to have antibodies. How would that remotely qualify as evidence that the vaccination caused the stroke?
Blood clots are one of the known and recognized side effects of these vaccines, some manufacturers more than others. Don't act like it's so far outside the realm of possibility.
I'm not. I'm questioning what the implication of being refused an antibody test is supposed to be. There doesn't seem to be any question of whether he had the vaccine. What would screening for antibodies prove? It's irrelevant but is included in the anecdote as though it shows some malfeasance on the part of the medical team.
I’m pretty sure this is just confusion on the part of someone who’s not a medical expert. There are different kinds of antibodies. Testing for antibodies against the coronavirus would, as you said, be pointless since they would be expected in someone who had received the vaccine. However, in someone having an autoimmune reaction to a vaccine, a test will reveal antibodies against their own body’s neural cells, called antigangliocide antibodies. It would be quite reasonable to ask for such a test, especially since the wife was a medical professional, and not outside the realm of possibility for a small hospital’s ER to be staffed with dummies who refused it, since Guillain-Barre is pretty rare and one of those things that gets misdiagnosed by doctors who aren’t looking for it.
In any case, it has nothing to do with blood clots, which is a whole different thing. Testing for antibodies would not reveal whether a blood clot that caused a stroke was the result of the vaccine, there is no simple test for that. And finding that a blood clot caused a stroke would mean that it wasn’t Guillain-Barre.9 -
Not delighted to read in the news today that my state, Tennessee, is rationing monoclonal antibodies. Specifically people who have been vaccinated can no longer receive them unless they are immunocompromised. So, if I get Covid, someone like me, a diabetic at high risk of hospitalization even with the vaccine, cannot receive them, even though I have been doing everything right and being responsible. Only irresponsible people who refuse to get vaccinated are now eligible for the best medical care.
I feel like if you are going to choose to be fearmongering about modern science, you shouldn’t get to change your mind later and grab all the goodies medical science has to offer, stealing them from people who didn’t make the same choice.32 -
rheddmobile wrote: »Not delighted to read in the news today that my state, Tennessee, is rationing monoclonal antibodies. Specifically people who have been vaccinated can no longer receive them unless they are immunocompromised. So, if I get Covid, someone like me, a diabetic at high risk of hospitalization even with the vaccine, cannot receive them, even though I have been doing everything right and being responsible. Only irresponsible people who refuse to get vaccinated are now eligible for the best medical care.
I feel like if you are going to choose to be fearmongering about modern science, you shouldn’t get to change your mind later and grab all the goodies medical science has to offer, stealing them from people who didn’t make the same choice.
Agreed! In my town in Texas is a hospital that offers antibody infusions and serves 5 counties (other nearby hospitals do not have this available). They have today increased capacity to now be able to provide 50 infusions daily (was about 30 before today). It is hopeful that this will keep people out of hospitals and open up some beds.
However, I agree with you... if there were plenty of capacity for hospital beds or moniclonal antibody infusions, I could accept giving them to people who refused vaccines. But that's not the situation. When care must be rationed, it should go to responsible patients first.18 -
rheddmobile wrote: »Not delighted to read in the news today that my state, Tennessee, is rationing monoclonal antibodies. Specifically people who have been vaccinated can no longer receive them unless they are immunocompromised. So, if I get Covid, someone like me, a diabetic at high risk of hospitalization even with the vaccine, cannot receive them, even though I have been doing everything right and being responsible. Only irresponsible people who refuse to get vaccinated are now eligible for the best medical care.
I feel like if you are going to choose to be fearmongering about modern science, you shouldn’t get to change your mind later and grab all the goodies medical science has to offer, stealing them from people who didn’t make the same choice.
Yeah, apparently, the latest "thing" among the unvaccinated is that they don't trust the vaccine because it's "new and untested", but they are clamoring for the monoclonal antibody infusions.
Here's a NY Times article about it:
https://www.nytimes.com/2021/09/18/health/covid-antibody-regeneron.html
Here's some quotes from the article:
“The people you love, you trust, nobody said anything negative about it,” Mr. Jones said of the antibody treatment. “And I’ve heard nothing but negative things about the side effects of the vaccine and how quickly it was developed.”
Within days of his infusion, Mr. Jones, the patient in Houston, had left the bedroom where he had been quarantined and returned to his work as a landscape architect. But he was still weighing whether to be vaccinated.
His doctor was pushing for the shot, he said. But the monoclonal antibodies had worked so well that he was tempted to simply return for another infusion if he caught Covid-19 again.
7
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions